Our 5-star rating system is nuanced. Learn how ratings are calculated, what each score band represents, and how to use them to find the best finds.
Every item in the USFans Spreadsheet carries a star rating, but those stars represent more than a simple "good or bad" judgment. Our rating algorithm weighs six distinct factors to produce a composite score that tells you exactly what kind of purchase experience to expect. Understanding this system transforms you from a casual browser into a strategic buyer.
The Rating Formula
25%
Accuracy to Retail
20%
Material Quality
20%
Build & Stitching
15%
Value for Money
10%
Seller Reliability
10%
Community Feedback
What Each Score Range Means
Score Range Breakdown
4.5+ Stars: Buy with Confidence
- Retail-level accuracy on logos and details
- Premium materials, no shortcuts
- Consistent sizing, reliable fit
- Active seller with fast shipping
- Strong community photo evidence
3.0-4.0: Know What You're Getting
- Minor accuracy flaws visible up close
- Acceptable materials, not premium
- May need size adjustment
- Functional but not exceptional
- Budget option, fair for the price
Important Note
A 4.2-rated item at $18 can be better value than a 4.7-rated item at $65. The rating measures absolute quality, but your personal "value score" depends on what you are willing to spend. Use ratings alongside price to make the smartest choice.
